Croatia Vacations

    Hvar or Brač? How to Choose the Right Island

    Hvar and Brač lie side by side off Split, but they feel very different. An honest comparison of getting there, beaches, towns, families and where to stay – with our villas on both islands.

    By Croatia Vacations ·

    6 min read

    Hvar Island seen from above, Croatia

    Hvar and Brač lie side by side off Split, both reachable by ferry in an hour or two, and both promise clear water, stone villages and long summer evenings. Yet they feel surprisingly different. Hvar is the glamorous one, with a lively harbour town and some of the sunniest weather on the Adriatic. Brač is bigger, greener and calmer, with Croatia's most famous beach. This guide compares the two honestly, so you can choose the island – and the villa – that suits your holiday.

    Hvar and Brač at a glance

    • Brač – the largest island in central Dalmatia and the closest to Split. Known for Zlatni Rat beach at Bol, the white Brač stone, olive groves and quiet harbour villages. Best for families, slow days and easy arrival.

    • Hvar – long, narrow and sun-drenched, with lavender fields, vineyards and three very different towns: lively Hvar Town, historic Stari Grad and relaxed Jelsa. Best for couples, food lovers and anyone who wants a little buzz in the evening.

    Both islands have quiet corners and both have beaches you will remember. The real difference is the rhythm of the day – and how much time you want to spend getting there.

    Aerial view of the bay and village of Splitska on BračStone house above the rocky shore on the south coast of Hvar

    Getting there from Split

    Brač is the easy one. Car ferries cross from Split to Supetar many times a day in summer and take about 50 minutes, so you can be at your villa an hour after leaving the port. There is also a catamaran to Bol and a small airport near Bol with seasonal flights.

    Hvar takes a little longer. The car ferry from Split to Stari Grad takes about two hours; fast catamarans run to Hvar Town and Jelsa in roughly an hour, but without a car. From the south, a short car ferry links Drvenik on the mainland with Sućuraj at Hvar's eastern tip – handy if you are driving up from Dubrovnik, although Sućuraj is a long drive from the rest of the island.

    If you would rather not think about timetables at all, we arrange private transfers from Split airport to your door – by car and ferry, or by private boat straight to the island.

    Beaches

    Brač has the postcard: Zlatni Rat at Bol, a long pebble spit that changes shape with the wind and currents. Around it, the south coast has quieter coves, and the north coast between Supetar and Postira has small pebble beaches and pine shade close to the villages.

    Hvar's beaches are mostly coves rather than long strands. The south coast around Zavala, Sveta Nedjelja and Ivan Dolac hides some of the clearest water on the island, and from Hvar Town water taxis run to the Pakleni islands, a chain of pine-covered islets with beach bars and secluded bays. Near Jelsa, Grebišće bay is an easy, family-friendly swim.

    In short: for one famous beach and easy swimming, Brač. For many small coves and a day of island-hopping by boat, Hvar.

    Towns, food and evenings

    Hvar Town is the island's stage: a Venetian square, a fortress above the harbour, yachts along the quay and bars that stay busy late into the night in July and August. Just 20 minutes away, Stari Grad – founded by Greek settlers in 384 BC – is quieter and more local, and Jelsa has a lovely harbour square for slow dinners.

    Brač is calmer after dark. Bol has the liveliest evenings, Supetar is a practical little town by the ferry, and harbour villages such as Splitska, Postira and Milna are made for long dinners by the water. Inland, Pučišća keeps the island's stonemasonry tradition alive and Škrip is one of its oldest settlements.

    Both islands take food seriously: lamb and fish from the grill, olive oil from the family press and local wines – on Hvar especially the reds from the south slopes and the whites of the Stari Grad Plain.

    Nature, peace and space

    Brač is the larger island and it feels it: pine forests, dry-stone walls and wide views from Vidova Gora, at 778 metres the highest peak of the Adriatic islands. Hvar's interior is a patchwork of vineyards, olive groves and lavender, with the Stari Grad Plain – an ancient Greek field system and UNESCO World Heritage Site – between Stari Grad and Jelsa.

    If peace is the priority, both islands deliver once you are away from Hvar Town in high season. The villages of central Hvar and the north coast of Brač are quiet even in August.

    Villa A Maria with its pool and terraces in the green interior of HvarVineyards and the village of Svirče on Hvar

    Families and groups

    For families with young children, Brač usually wins: the short ferry, gentle pebble beaches near the villages and a calmer atmosphere make the logistics easy. Hvar works beautifully for families too if you stay away from Hvar Town – the bays near Jelsa and the quiet interior villages are relaxed and safe.

    Groups of friends often prefer Hvar for the mix of quiet villa days and an evening or two in Hvar Town. For larger groups, a villa with its own pool matters more than the island – somewhere everyone can gather after a day at the beach.

    Where to stay: our villas on Hvar and Brač

    We have personally chosen three homes on the two islands:

    • Villa Marisol in Splitska on Brač – a restored villa with a pool, ten metres from the sea and about five kilometres from the Supetar ferry. Sleeps up to eight.

    • Villa A Maria above Svirče in central Hvar – a hillside family villa with a pool and views over vineyards, about nine kilometres from the Stari Grad ferry. Sleeps up to ten.

    • Stone House Bogić Kuća in Zavala on Hvar's south coast – a restored 1913 stone house right on the water, for two to four guests who want complete privacy.

    All three are booked directly with us, without platform fees, and we arrange transfers and boat days around your stay.

    Can you combine both islands?

    Yes – and from a villa on either island it is easy. From Brač, a private boat reaches Hvar's Pakleni islands or the south coast in well under two hours; from Hvar, Bol and Zlatni Rat are a short hop across the channel. A private boat day with your own skipper is the most relaxed way to see both islands without changing accommodation.

    With ten days or more, you could also split your stay: a few nights on Brač for the beach and easy arrival, then Hvar for its towns and wine.

    Our verdict

    Choose Brač if you want the shortest journey from Split, gentle beaches for children and quiet evenings in a harbour village. Choose Hvar if you want variety – lively Hvar Town, historic Stari Grad, vineyards, lavender and many small coves to explore by boat.

    Still undecided? Tell us your dates, who is travelling and what matters most, and we will suggest the island – and the villa – that fits.

    Quick answers

    Which is closer to Split, Hvar or Brač?

    Brač. The car ferry from Split to Supetar takes about 50 minutes; the car ferry to Stari Grad on Hvar takes about two hours, and the catamaran to Hvar Town about an hour.

    Is Hvar or Brač better for families?

    Brač is usually easier for young families thanks to the short ferry and calm village beaches. Hvar is great for families too if you stay outside Hvar Town, for example near Jelsa or in the interior villages.

    Which island has better beaches?

    Brač has Zlatni Rat, Croatia's best-known beach. Hvar has more small coves, especially on the south coast and on the Pakleni islands opposite Hvar Town.

    Can I visit both islands in one holiday?

    Yes. From a villa on either island, a private boat day reaches the other one easily, and with ten days or more you can split your stay between them.

    Journal

    More stories

    All articles →

    Beaches

    Grebišće Beach, Jelsa: A Sandy Beach on Hvar

    Discover the rare sandy shores and vibrant coastal spirit of Grebišće, a sun-drenched bay near Jelsa that offers a perfect day of relaxation on the island of Hvar. Whether you are wading through its shallow turquoise waters or enjoying a world-class cocktail at the iconic Beach Bar Grebišće, this hidden gem is an essential stop for anyone seeking the authentic "pomalo" island lifestyle.

    Read: Grebišće Beach, Jelsa: A Sandy Beach on Hvar

    Beaches

    Prapratno Beach: A Sandy Bay on the Pelješac Peninsula

    Discover the rare beauty of Prapratno, a stunning sandy oasis on the Pelješac Peninsula where turquoise waters and golden shores create a Mediterranean dream for families and nature lovers alike. Located just a scenic 25-minute drive from the historic luxury of Villa Schola, this sheltered bay offers the perfect day trip to experience one of Croatia’s most beautiful beaches and the primary gateway to Mljet National Park.

    Read: Prapratno Beach: A Sandy Bay on the Pelješac Peninsula

    Experiences

    Mljet Island & National Park: Croatia's Greenest Island

    Experience the ethereal beauty of Mljet National Park, Croatia's greenest island, where ancient pine forests meet the legendary saltwater lakes and the mythical Odysseus Cave. Staying at Villa Schola in Brsečine places you just a 25-minute drive from the ferry gateway, making it the perfect base to explore this soulful island before returning to your private Mediterranean sanctuary.

    Read: Mljet Island & National Park: Croatia's Greenest Island